Bāgh-o-Bahār is not only an important Urdu classic, it has also been of great interest to researchers and has been cited more than once. This article reviews two of the best known edited versions of this book, one by Rashid Hasan Khan and the other by Mirza Hamid Baig. Although both researchers enjoy authentic credentials, there are several points of contradiction in the two versions, whereas both the researchers have also given strong arguments for their finndings. This article studies the differences between these versions.